Fat Witch Bakery

Bakery, 75 9th Ave, New York, NY

VeganScore 10

Menu

Desserts

• Halloween Baby — A spooky-season favorite! Our limited-edition Halloween Baby Witch is here for a limited time.
• Pumpkin Caramel Baby — A fall favorite! Our Pumpkin Caramel Baby combines warm pumpkin spice with rich caramel and our signature fudgy brownie.
• Peanut Butter Baby — Our rich, fudgy Baby Witch meets creamy peanut butter. A classic combination you won’t want to miss!
• Fat Witch Baby — This is where the magic began. Our original brownie — rich, satisfying, and deeply chocolatey — made for those moments when only a true classic will do.
• Walnut Baby — A hearty twist on our classic brownie! With rich chocolate and bits of walnut in every bite, this little square packs bold flavor and wholesome charm — ready to enjoy in just 2–3 bites.
• Blonde Baby — Light, soft, and full of charm — the Blonde Baby blends vanilla richness with chunks of dark chocolate. It’s like a brownie and a chocolate chip cookie had the perfect bite-sized baby.
• Caramel Baby — Smooth caramel meets classic brownie in every bite. Just 2-3 bites of sweet, gooey perfection that’ll keep you coming back for more.
• Snow Baby — Bright, creamy, and oh-so-smooth! This white chocolate brownie with a hint of vanilla is like a sweet little snowflake you can eat anytime.
• Double Chocolate Baby — Twice the chocolate, twice the fun! This brownie’s packed with rich chocolate and extra chips for a seriously delicious, can’t-stop-at-one kind of treat.
• Red Baby — A little tart, a little sweet, and a whole lot of attitude—this velvety chocolate brownie swirls in tangy cherry for a bold bite that keeps you coming back for more.
• Apple Cinnamon Baby — Sweet, spiced, and full of fall flavor, this brownie brings the warm taste of apple and cinnamon in every bite.
• Almond Baby — This little brownie’s got a nutty side—rich chocolate swirled with toasted almond slices and slivers for a bold, crunchy bite that’s anything but basic.
• Yuzu Baby — Say hello to Yuzu Baby – a white chocolate-based brownie with a refreshing citrusy twist! Infused with the bright, tangy flavor of yuzu, this soft and delicate treat brings a perfect balance of sweet and zesty.
• Sesame Baby — Nutty, toasty, and totally unexpected—this brownie blends rich chocolate with crunchy toasted sesame seeds for a flavor combo that’s deliciously different.
• Pumpkin Witch — Celebrate fall with our limited-edition Pumpkin Witch, featuring warm pumpkin spice and our signature fudgy brownie. Available for a limited time.
• Fat Witch — Born from pure chocolate passion, our original brownie casts a rich, classic spell you just can’t resist.
• Walnut Witch — The Walnut Witch is rich, chocolatey, and full of nutty charm. A classic brownie with hearty walnut pieces in every bite.
• Blonde Witch — Golden, soft, and just the right amount of sweet — the Blonde Witch blends vanilla and chocolate into a treat you’ll keep reaching for.
• Caramel Witch — The Caramel Witch swirls buttery caramel into rich chocolate brownie for a sweet, smooth finish in every bite.
• Snow Witch — The Snow Witch is smooth, sweet, and full of white chocolate magic — a creamy twist on our classic that’s impossible to resist.
• Double Chocolate Witch — Twice the chocolate, twice the charm — the Double Chocolate Witch is a bold take on our classic.

Start your free trial